Our Rating

4.4

Guilty Sea Sports Pub - Indian Rocks Beach is rated
4.4 out of 5.0 based on 1264 reviews

We Love Reviews! Please click on one of the sites below to leave us a review.
Erin J May 29, 2026

We’ve been in town all week exploring and had only eaten out once before this, which unfortunately wasn’t a great experience. We were hesitant to try one of the more touristy, commercialized seafood spots, so we decided to give Guilty Sea a try—and we’re so glad we did! We each ordered a cocktail, and both were delicious. Since it was a Thursday night, we took advantage of the wing special, and wow—those wings were phenomenal. As Connecticut residents who live near one of the top-rated wing destinations in the country, we were genuinely impressed. The mozzarella sticks were excellent, and the Caesar salad was fresh and delicious. We were so happy we chose a local restaurant, and it ended up being one of our favorite meals of the trip. Highly recommend!

Erin Joudrey May 29, 2026

We’ve been in town all week exploring and had only eaten out once before this, which unfortunately wasn’t a great experience. We were hesitant to try one of the more touristy, commercialized seafood spots, so we decided to give Guilty Sea a try—and we’re so glad we did! We each ordered a cocktail, and both were delicious. Since it was a Thursday night, we took advantage of the wing special, and wow—those wings were phenomenal. As Connecticut residents who live near one of the top-rated wing destinations in the country, we were genuinely impressed. The mozzarella sticks were excellent, and the Caesar salad was fresh and delicious. We were so happy we chose a local restaurant, and it ended up being one of our favorite meals of the trip. Highly recommend!

Mickey Jankowski May 28, 2026

Visiting the area with my fiancé and stopped by Guilty Seas during the early evening since we aren’t used to this heat from walking around all day. Ended up being trivia night which made for a pretty funny experience. Isiah was super knowledgeable and helpful with her questions, and Allie our bartender was really friendly and good too. Definitely a fun spot with a laid back vibe.

Tim H. May 28, 2026

Sabrina was the best server. Checked on us frequently and was fun and friendly. $10 smash burger was excellent. Hockey game on TV made it even better. Nice and cool inside too

Derek D. May 28, 2026

Great food and atmosphere. Service is always great! Bring an appetite! The 85 character limit seems superfluous. Sabrina was great tonight as our server.