I came in with some friends and I must say, what a wonderful experience. I had the twinkie appetizer and it was phenomenal. Isaiah, the manager then came over to check on us and recommended the pizza. He was very nice and knowledgeable. I ordered the meat pizza my friends had the margarita pizza! Everything was good, the servers, bartenders what a great service and team. Then we played pool and had drinks. We will definitely return.

As a long-time patron of Guilty Sea Sports Pub, I wanted to take a moment to recognize just how amazing the staff, food, and service are. Desiree and Rachel have to be the top bartending team on the beach. They serve premium cocktails with quick, attentive service and have a true passion for what they do while taking great care of the local community. Cal is another standout—an incredible bartender and server who always takes the time to say hello and check in on how I’m doing, even when I’m not sitting in his section. That kind of genuine hospitality goes a long way. The management team, led by Isaiah, is nothing short of professional. No matter how busy things get, Isaiah always finds a way to stop by and make sure my experience has been great. The hostess crew is also fantastic—they not only run an efficient dining room, but always take the time to greet everyone and wish guests a wonderful evening. That really shows how much the staff and management care about their guests and how everyone there works together as an efficient team. Add in great food, plenty of TVs and sports packages so you can catch any game, and a beautiful beach sunset directly across from a beach access, and it’s easy to see why this is my top recommendation for a fantastic beachside pub on the island. My only complaint… please get rid of that terrible Parking LLC you use. They “ticket” staff and guests visiting and while I understand the issues of parking on the island, this is not the solution.

Dinner was really good, the cheese pull on the mozzarella sticks was incredible, same as their taste. I got the breaded flounder and it was delicious.

Reviewer Did Not Provide A Comment

Excellent food with great selection reasonably priced. We had crab legs.. yum